Fresh Cheese: Cultures Of Confusion
Whey To Go ~ January 2007
My name is Stephanie Zonis, and welcome to Whey to Go! for January, 2007. Every month, we’ll delve into a new cheese-related subject, and I’ll offer a recommendation on a cheese I love. This month it’s fresh cheeses: not every fresh cheese made, or you’d be here reading until next month. But, here’s a selection of delicious fresh cheeses that you should get to know better, if you aren’t already on intimate terms.
You’ve heard their names before: quark, fromage blanc, crème fraîche, mascarpone, labné and queso fresco. This is a sextet that makes even lactophiles shake their heads bewilderedly. They’re all more-or-less cheeses, you know that much, but what’s the difference among them? Can they be used interchangeably in recipes? And fat content is a big concern for many people these days; which of these products is lowest in fat? As Yul Brynner once observed in his role as the King of Siam, “Is a puzzlement!”
Let’s start with some of easiest cheeses on the list: mascarpone, and queso fresco and queso blanco: all cow’s milk cheeses.
Mascarpone is sometimes referred to as “Italian cream cheese.” It’s softer and richer than American-style cream cheese, to be sure, but genuine mascarpone has less of a tang than does cream cheese made in the U.S. Mascarpone has an extraordinarily high butterfat content, unsurprising given that it’s made from the cream skimmed from cow’s milk. Truly fresh mascarpone has almost a sweet flavor, and this is a cheese with very low or no sodium. Like all of the cheeses discussed here, it’s highly perishable and must be kept cold. While some think mascarpone is the a chief component of cannolis, it is actually ricotta: Mascarpone or ricotta is used in Italian cheesecake.
Hispanic foods are becoming increasingly popular in American society (and about time, too!). From these cultures, we get queso fresco, one of the most commonly-used cheeses in Latin America. It’s a soft, mild cheese similar to ricotta in that it’s made from curds. Cultures and rennet are added to pasteurized milk to create the curds, which are scooped into molds, then drained briefly. The resulting queso fresco is crumbly, with a mild and salty flavor and a slightly “grainy” texture. It is often sprinkled over foods, and when heated, it will melt. Queso fresco is most often used crumbled, as a topping for everything from salads to soups to enchiladas, and is melted in quesadillas and casseroles. Queso fresco should not be confused with queso blanco fresco, although the latter is similar. Queso blanco fresco is a fresh cheese that is made by direct acidification (not cultures and rennet) and pressed into blocks. It consequently has a firm texture and softens but does not melt: It can be sliced for pan-frying.
We had to digress and share this delicious recipe from Mozzarella Company, one of our Top Picks Of The Week:
For The Caramelized Onions
Time to move on to another country and another soft, fresh cheese. It is from Lebanon that we received the gift of labné, also known as kefir, the Lebanese version of cream cheese. In a nutshell, labné is a yogurt cheese, but it is often quite rich. The flavor is slightly tart and refreshing. In its country of origin, it is most commonly viewed as a staple of the breakfast table, but in the U.S. it is more often used as a dip for veggies and/or pita bread—although it spreads wonderfully on toast and bagels and its slight tartness is a delightful complement to jam. As a dip with toasted pita, serve on a plate with a depression in the middle, filled with extra virgin olive oil, sprinkle with chopped fresh mint leaves or thyme, and surround with black Mediterranean olives. Or serve with chopped mint as a side to roast lamb. Popular throughout the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East, there are Middle Eastern restaurants in which a good labné can be a highlight of the meal.
Crème fraîche, a relative of sour cream, is actually not a cheese because it is not made from curd, but it is similar in consistency to products that are curd-based. The regions of Normandy and Brittany in France were the likely birthplace of crème fraîche, one of the true glories of French cuisine. It is cultured cream from cow’s milk, thickened with an acid and treated with mild heat just until it achieves a silken-smooth texture and substantial thickness. Crème fraîche will be tangy like sour cream, but it’s a much more lightweight, elegant product, and like sour cream, it should be perfectly smooth. Crème fraîche embraces everything from the savory (caviar and smoked salmon) to the sweet (fresh berries and the richest chocolate cake), but it isn’t easy on the waistline. It’s so good, you’ll want to eat it by the cupful; but like at 110 calories an ounce, that 8-ounce cup is more caloric than a slice of cheesecake.
So far, everything has been straightforward. You should now be able to distinguish between mascarpone and queso fresco, labné and crème Fraîche, without the aid of a microscope or a lengthy investigation. Hold on to that thought, because now we’re moving to quark and fromage blanc, and it can be far more difficult to tell the difference between these two cheeses.
We’ll begin with quark, which has a literary relationship to the subatomic particles*, but is first and foremost the German word for curds. The knowledgeable Steven Jenkins, in his outstanding book, Cheese Primer, tells us that quark “can best be described as a cross between yogurt and American curdless or small-curd cottage cheese.” He adds that quark originated in Germany and/or western Austria and is similar to another fresh cheese, called “topfen” (pot cheese—and also is similar to ricotta). It may be made from cow’s goat’s, or sheep’s milk, or a mixture of two or more of those. A white and unaged cheese, it is made by letting lactic acid bacteria (sometimes also rennet) ferment milk, which produces the resulting curd. Some or most of the whey is removed by hanging the cheese in cheesecloth and letting it drip off, to achieve the desired thickness. This gives handmade European quark its distinctive shape of a wedge with rounded edges; in commercial production it is formed into blocks.
*In German, Quark and Topfen, the names of cheeses, are also used to mean “nonsense.” This latter usage is believed to be an inspiration for the passage written by James Joyce in his fanciful novel, Finnegan’s Wake: “Three quarks for Muster Mark!/Sure he hasn’t got much of a bark/And sure any he has it’s all beside the mark.” This excerpt is from a 13-line poem directed against King Mark, the cuckolded husband in the Tristan and Isolde legend. Use of the word “quark” to describe elementary particles of matter was taken from this poem by Murray Gell-Mann, the physicist who received the 1969 Nobel Prize for his work in classifying quarks. The allusion to three quarks seemed perfect to him, since originally there were only three subatomic quarks.
In the United States and Canada, quark is a somewhat different product, often sold in plastic tubs with most or all of the whey. This type of quark has the texture of yogurt or sour cream and is not necessarily low in fat—so if you want a low-fat cheese, make sure to check the product label. While the European, curd-type quark is a mild cheese, the American, yogurt-consistency quarks tend to be on the tangy side. The texture of domestic quarks will also vary by producer: They can resemble thick yogurt or be of a denser, more spreadable consistency.
Fromage blanc is a fresh cream cheese that can be very similar to both quark and crème fraîche. Again, the final consistency and flavor is entirely up to the manufacturer. It’s another soft cheese, but how soft, and how tangy a flavor it has, is all in the production. Fromage blanc can have more of a curd than quark, but it doesn’t always. It may or may not be low in fat. Because there is no federal standard of identity for either product in the U.S., one manufacturer’s fromage blanc could be another’s quark! The fromage blanc from Vermont Butter & Cheese, for example, is extremely soft, with the consistency of sour cream and a similar tang, but with a significantly lower fat content and calorie count.
How about recipe use? If a recipe calls for mascarpone and you can’t find any, is it O.K. to use quark or crème fraîche? The answer is that none of these cheeses is always interchangeable. Queso fresco is probably going to be the saltiest and crumbliest of the six; mascarpone will likely be the sweetest and richest. You might be able to get away with a dollop of mascarpone instead of queso fresco on top of a serving of bean soup, but I wouldn’t try a reverse substitution in my best chocolate cheesecake! Crème fraîche can sometimes be used instead of mascarpone (as a soup or fruit topping, perhaps), just as quark and fromage blanc may be interchangeable in some food applications (depending upon texture and tartness), but it’s always a bit of a gamble.
Not everyone considers all of these to be “real” cheeses, as some never see separation of curds from whey. To me, that’s splitting hairs. But call them what you like, as long as you try them. There are many brands of most of these cheeses available, and it’s absolutely delightful to find one you really like and will use over and over again. “Genuine” cheese or not, it’s all about expanding your culinary and gustatory horizons.
When you can find four of the six cheeses I discuss in one edition in one convenient place, you’re doing well for yourself. And when they’re of good quality, you’re doing even better! Vermont Butter and Cheese Company makes crème fraîche, mascarpone, quark, and fromage blanc (in addition to a few aged cheeses, a few goat’s milk cheeses, and a delicious cultured butter). This company has a remarkable story behind it, but, more importantly to my way of thinking, they’ve really kept up their standards through their 20+ years in business. I have never had a product from them that wasn’t well-made.
© Copyright 2005-2013 Lifestyle Direct, Inc. All rights reserved. Images are the copyright of their respective owners.
Manufacturers & Retailers